A commercial contract establishes the rights and obligations agreed between businesses. When one party fails to perform those obligations, performs them incorrectly or indicates that it will not perform them, the other party may face financial loss, operational disruption and uncertainty about what to do next.

Not every breach gives a business the same rights. Depending on the contract and the seriousness of the breach, the innocent party may be entitled to claim damages, recover an unpaid debt, require performance in limited circumstances, seek an injunction or, in sufficiently serious cases, terminate the contract.

The correct response should therefore begin with the contract itself and the circumstances surrounding the alleged breach.

This guide explains common forms of commercial contract breach in England and Wales, the remedies potentially available to businesses, the importance of evidence and pre-action procedure, and when specialist legal advice may be appropriate.

Please note: this article provides general information about the law of England and Wales and does not constitute legal advice. Contract disputes are highly fact-specific and the wording of the agreement can significantly affect the parties’ rights.

What Is a Breach of Commercial Contract?

A breach of contract occurs when a party fails to comply with an obligation imposed by a legally binding contract.

In a commercial relationship, this might involve a failure to:

  • pay an invoice or other sum when due;
  • deliver goods;
  • provide contracted services;
  • meet an agreed deadline;
  • achieve a contractual specification;
  • comply with confidentiality obligations;
  • respect exclusivity arrangements;
  • perform agreed milestones;
  • comply with warranties or undertakings; or
  • perform another contractual obligation.

Commercial contracts can vary considerably, so identifying a breach usually requires careful analysis of the actual contractual wording rather than simply deciding that the other party has behaved unfairly.

Businesses entering international or complex agreements may also find our guide to international commercial contracts and cross-border business useful.

What Are Common Commercial Contract Disputes?

Contract disputes can arise across almost every industry.

Common examples include:

  • non-payment for goods or services;
  • failure to deliver goods on time;
  • services allegedly falling below contractual standards;
  • disputes over pricing or additional charges;
  • failure to meet project milestones;
  • termination disputes;
  • breach of confidentiality;
  • breach of restrictive contractual provisions;
  • disputes concerning warranties or representations;
  • interpretation of contractual clauses;
  • disputes over variation of the contract;
  • failure to supply agreed quantities;
  • software or technology implementation disputes;
  • distribution and agency disputes; and
  • cross-border disputes concerning governing law or jurisdiction.

The commercial consequences can extend well beyond the value of a single unpaid invoice. A breach may interrupt a supply chain, delay a project, affect customers or cause wider financial losses.

Does Every Breach Allow You to Terminate the Contract?

No.

This is one of the most important issues in commercial contract disputes.

A breach may give the innocent party a right to claim damages without necessarily providing a right to terminate the entire agreement.

The right to terminate may arise from:

  • an express termination provision in the contract;
  • a breach of a contractual condition;
  • a sufficiently serious breach of an intermediate term; or
  • a repudiatory breach under the general law.

Wrongfully terminating a contract can itself amount to a serious breach.

For this reason, a business should be cautious before sending a termination notice or treating the contract as having ended.

What Is a Repudiatory Breach of Contract?

A repudiatory breach is a sufficiently serious breach that may entitle the innocent party to accept the breach, terminate future performance of the contract and seek damages.

Whether a particular breach is repudiatory depends on the contractual terms and circumstances.

It should not simply be assumed that every significant commercial problem allows immediate termination.

A party faced with an apparent repudiatory breach may also have to decide whether to accept the breach and terminate or affirm the contract and keep it in force.

That decision can have major legal and commercial consequences and should normally be made carefully.

What Is an Anticipatory Breach?

An anticipatory breach can arise where, before performance is due, one party clearly indicates that it will not perform its contractual obligations.

For example, a supplier may inform a customer that it will not make an agreed delivery, or a contracting party may state clearly that it no longer intends to perform the agreement.

Depending on the seriousness and legal effect of the conduct, the innocent party may have options before the date for performance actually arrives.

However, deciding whether a communication or action amounts to a legally effective repudiation requires careful analysis.

What Should a Business Do When a Contract Is Breached?

The first response should usually be strategic rather than emotional.

Before terminating the contract, withholding payments or starting court proceedings, a business should consider:

  1. What does the signed contract actually say?
  2. Which obligation has allegedly been breached?
  3. Is there a notice or cure procedure?
  4. Does the contract require written notification?
  5. Is there a contractual dispute resolution procedure?
  6. What losses have actually been caused?
  7. What documents and communications support the position?
  8. Does the contract contain a limitation or exclusion of liability?
  9. Which country’s law governs the agreement?
  10. Which court or arbitral tribunal has jurisdiction?

Taking action before answering these questions can sometimes weaken an otherwise strong contractual position.

Check the Notice Provisions Carefully

Commercial agreements frequently contain detailed notice clauses.

They may specify:

  • how notice must be given;
  • the address to which it must be sent;
  • whether email is permitted;
  • when notice is deemed received;
  • who must receive the notice; and
  • how much time the other party has to remedy a breach.

If a business wishes to exercise a contractual right of termination or another important remedy, compliance with the contractual notice procedure can be critical.

What Remedies Are Available for Breach of Commercial Contract?

The appropriate remedy depends on the contract, the breach, the loss and the commercial objective.

Possible remedies may include:

  • damages;
  • recovery of a contractual debt;
  • termination where legally available;
  • specific performance in appropriate circumstances;
  • injunctive relief;
  • declaratory relief;
  • contractual remedies specifically agreed between the parties; or
  • a negotiated settlement.

Not every remedy will be available in every dispute.

Damages for Breach of Contract

Damages are one of the principal remedies for breach of contract.

The purpose of contractual damages is generally compensatory rather than punitive. The court will consider the loss legally caused by the breach and whether that loss falls within the applicable principles governing recoverability.

Issues commonly arising when calculating damages include:

  • causation;
  • remoteness of loss;
  • mitigation;
  • evidence of financial loss;
  • contractual limitations of liability; and
  • whether particular categories of loss have been excluded.

Can a Business Claim Lost Profits?

Loss of profit may potentially form part of a contractual damages claim, but it is not automatically recoverable simply because a breach occurred.

The claimant will generally need to establish the relevant loss and demonstrate the necessary connection between the breach and the claimed financial consequences.

The contract itself may also contain provisions limiting or excluding claims for particular categories of loss.

Financial records, forecasts, previous trading results, contracts with customers and expert evidence can become relevant depending on the scale and complexity of the claim.

What Is the Duty to Mitigate Loss?

A claimant generally cannot allow avoidable losses to accumulate indefinitely and then expect the defendant to compensate them in full.

The innocent party should normally take reasonable steps to mitigate losses arising from the breach.

Depending on the circumstances, mitigation could involve:

  • finding an alternative supplier;
  • purchasing replacement goods;
  • reallocating staff or resources;
  • seeking alternative customers; or
  • taking practical action to prevent losses increasing.

What is reasonable will depend on the facts of the individual dispute.

Can You Recover an Unpaid Contractual Debt?

Some commercial claims are primarily claims for a debt rather than damages.

For example, one business may have supplied goods or completed contracted services and issued an invoice that remains unpaid.

The legal and procedural considerations involved in recovering a fixed contractual debt can differ from a claim seeking compensation for wider losses caused by a breach.

The underlying contract, invoices, delivery records, acceptance records and correspondence can all be important evidence.

Can the Court Order the Other Party to Perform the Contract?

In some circumstances, a party may seek specific performance, asking the court to require the other party to perform a contractual obligation.

Specific performance is a discretionary equitable remedy and is not granted automatically.

Damages are often the primary remedy for commercial breach, and whether specific performance is appropriate depends on the circumstances.

Can a Business Obtain an Injunction?

Injunctions may be relevant where damages alone would not adequately protect the claimant’s position.

For example, urgent relief may potentially be considered in disputes involving confidential information, restrictive obligations, intellectual property, disposal of assets or threatened conduct that may cause serious harm.

Applications for injunctions require careful preparation and can involve additional duties where urgent relief is sought.

Preserve Evidence as Soon as a Dispute Starts

Evidence can determine the strength of a commercial contract claim.

Businesses should consider preserving:

  • the signed contract and amendments;
  • purchase orders;
  • invoices;
  • delivery records;
  • emails;
  • letters;
  • WhatsApp and other business messages;
  • meeting notes;
  • project reports;
  • technical documentation;
  • banking and payment records;
  • photographs;
  • internal records relating to loss; and
  • documents showing attempts to mitigate loss.

Deleting or losing important communications after a dispute arises can create serious evidential difficulties later.

Should You Send a Letter Before Action?

Before commencing most civil proceedings, parties are expected to follow any applicable pre-action protocol or, where there is no specific protocol, the Practice Direction on Pre-Action Conduct and Protocols.

The pre-action process generally aims to ensure that the parties understand each other’s positions, exchange relevant information, consider settlement and explore appropriate forms of alternative dispute resolution.

A letter before action will commonly set out matters such as:

  • the contractual basis of the claim;
  • the relevant facts;
  • the alleged breach;
  • the remedy sought;
  • the amount claimed where appropriate;
  • key supporting documents; and
  • a reasonable period for response.

The precise procedure depends on the type of claim.

The official Practice Direction on Pre-Action Conduct and Protocols provides further information.

Should Businesses Try to Settle Before Going to Court?

Yes, settlement should normally be considered seriously.

The Civil Procedure Rules encourage parties to exchange information and consider alternative dispute resolution before commencing proceedings.

A commercial settlement can sometimes achieve an outcome that litigation cannot, particularly where the parties wish to preserve a business relationship or agree new payment or performance arrangements.

Settlement options may include:

  • direct negotiation;
  • solicitor-led negotiation;
  • mediation;
  • structured payment arrangements;
  • variation of the contract;
  • commercial compromise; or
  • formal settlement agreements.

What Is Mediation in a Commercial Contract Dispute?

Mediation involves an independent mediator assisting the parties in attempting to reach a negotiated settlement.

The mediator does not normally impose a decision on the parties.

Mediation can be particularly useful where the parties want greater control over the outcome, confidentiality and an opportunity to preserve an ongoing commercial relationship.

When Does Commercial Litigation Become Necessary?

Court proceedings may become necessary where:

  • the parties cannot reach settlement;
  • the defendant denies liability;
  • substantial damages are disputed;
  • urgent court relief is required;
  • important contractual rights require determination; or
  • the limitation period requires protective action.

Litigation should be approached with a clear understanding of costs, evidence, commercial objectives and enforcement prospects.

BAIS advises businesses through its Dispute Resolution and Litigation practice.

What If the Contract Contains an Arbitration Clause?

Many international and high-value commercial agreements require disputes to be resolved through arbitration rather than ordinary court litigation.

Before commencing court proceedings, it is therefore essential to review the dispute resolution clause.

If a valid arbitration agreement applies to the dispute, the parties may be required to pursue the claim through arbitration.

For further information, read our guide to international commercial arbitration.

Where an arbitration has already concluded and the successful party needs to enforce an overseas award in England and Wales, see our guide to enforcing a foreign arbitral award.

International and Cross-Border Contract Disputes

Commercial contract disputes become more complex when the parties, performance or assets are located in different countries.

Important issues may include:

  • governing law;
  • court jurisdiction;
  • arbitration agreements;
  • service of proceedings abroad;
  • foreign evidence and translations;
  • parallel proceedings;
  • enforcement of judgments or arbitral awards; and
  • location of recoverable assets.

Businesses should not assume that the location of one party automatically determines which country’s law or courts apply.

What Is the Time Limit for a Breach of Contract Claim?

Limitation should be considered immediately when a dispute arises.

Under section 5 of the Limitation Act 1980, an action founded on a simple contract is generally subject to a six-year limitation period from the date on which the cause of action accrued.

Different rules may apply in particular circumstances, including certain agreements executed as deeds or specialties, and determining when a cause of action accrued can itself require legal analysis.

Businesses should therefore avoid waiting until the end of an apparent limitation period before obtaining advice.

Can Contractual Liability Be Limited?

Commercial contracts often contain clauses intended to limit exposure to liability.

These may include:

  • financial liability caps;
  • exclusions of particular types of loss;
  • notification deadlines;
  • exclusive remedy clauses;
  • warranty limitations; and
  • indemnity provisions.

The effectiveness and interpretation of such clauses depends on their wording and the applicable law.

A claimant should therefore review limitation provisions before calculating the value of a claim or deciding on litigation strategy.

What Should an International Business Do First?

Where a cross-border commercial contract has been breached, the business should ideally:

  1. secure the contract and all amendments;
  2. preserve communications and evidence;
  3. identify the precise contractual breach;
  4. review governing law and dispute resolution clauses;
  5. check notice requirements;
  6. calculate immediate and potential losses;
  7. take reasonable steps to mitigate those losses;
  8. identify relevant limitation periods; and
  9. consider legal advice before taking irreversible action.

When Should You Speak to a Commercial Dispute Solicitor?

Early legal advice may be particularly useful where:

  • the financial value of the dispute is substantial;
  • termination is being considered;
  • the other party has threatened proceedings;
  • there is an international element;
  • the contract contains an arbitration clause;
  • urgent injunctive relief may be required;
  • significant business disruption is occurring;
  • important limitation deadlines may be approaching; or
  • the dispute could affect a long-term commercial relationship.

Early advice can help clarify the strength of the contractual position before steps are taken that may later be difficult to reverse.

How B A International Solicitors Can Assist

B A International Solicitors advises businesses and international clients on commercial contracts, business disputes and cross-border legal matters.

Depending on the circumstances, assistance may include reviewing contractual rights, assessing alleged breaches, advising on termination, preparing or responding to pre-action correspondence, negotiating settlement and supporting clients through litigation or arbitration.

Relevant services include our Business and Commercial Law practice and our Dispute Resolution and Litigation team.

Frequently Asked Questions

What counts as a breach of a commercial contract?

A breach can occur when a party fails to perform a contractual obligation, performs it incorrectly or, in some circumstances, clearly indicates that it will not perform. The contract should be reviewed carefully to identify the obligation and legal consequences.

Can I terminate a contract if the other business breaches it?

Not automatically. The right to terminate depends on factors including the contractual terms and seriousness of the breach. Wrongful termination can itself create liability.

Can I claim compensation for breach of contract?

Damages may be available where recoverable loss has been caused by the breach. Questions of causation, remoteness, mitigation and contractual limitations can affect the amount recoverable.

Can I recover lost profit?

Potentially, but lost profits are not automatically recoverable. They need to be established and must satisfy the applicable legal principles and any contractual limitations.

Do I have to go to court?

No. Many commercial disputes are resolved through negotiation, mediation or other settlement mechanisms. Some contracts also require arbitration.

How long do I have to bring a breach of contract claim?

Claims founded on simple contracts are generally subject to a six-year limitation period in England and Wales, but different rules can apply. Advice should be obtained on the specific claim rather than relying solely on the general period.

What if the other party is overseas?

The governing law, jurisdiction or arbitration clause should be checked. Cross-border disputes may also involve questions about service, foreign evidence and enforcement against overseas or UK assets.

Speak to Our Commercial Dispute Solicitors

A breach of contract can quickly develop from a commercial disagreement into a significant financial and operational problem. The earlier the contract, evidence and available remedies are assessed, the easier it may be to make informed decisions about negotiation, termination, litigation or arbitration.

Contact B A International Solicitors to discuss a commercial contract dispute in England and Wales.