Construction projects often involve significant investment, complex contractual arrangements and multiple parties working under strict commercial deadlines. When disagreements arise, they can quickly lead to delayed projects, withheld payments, disrupted supply chains and substantial financial losses.

Construction disputes may involve developers, contractors, subcontractors, consultants, investors, property owners and international businesses. Resolving these disputes effectively requires an understanding not only of the underlying construction contract but also of the different dispute resolution procedures available in England and Wales.

Businesses facing these issues may benefit from obtaining specialist advice on construction law before a disagreement develops into formal adjudication, arbitration or court proceedings.

This guide examines some of the most common causes of construction disputes, the options available for resolving them and the steps businesses should consider when a disagreement begins to escalate.

Please note: this article provides general information and focuses primarily on the legal framework in England and Wales. Different rules may apply in Scotland, Northern Ireland and other jurisdictions. Specific legal advice should be obtained for individual circumstances.

What Is a Construction Dispute?

A construction dispute is a disagreement arising from a construction, engineering or building project. It may relate to payment, performance, contractual obligations, delays, defects, variations, professional services or the interpretation of the contract itself.

Some disputes develop gradually during a project, while others arise following a specific event such as non-payment, termination of a contract, a major delay or the discovery of defective work.

Because construction projects commonly involve several contracts and numerous parties, an apparently straightforward disagreement can quickly become complex. Identifying the contractual position and preserving relevant evidence at an early stage can therefore be important.

Where the dispute extends beyond purely technical construction issues, advice concerning dispute resolution and litigation may also become necessary.

Common Causes of Construction Disputes

Although every project is different, certain issues arise frequently in construction disputes.

Payment Disputes

Disagreements over payment are among the most common construction disputes. They may concern unpaid applications for payment, disputed valuations, withheld sums, retention payments, final accounts or disagreement over whether additional work should be paid for.

Payment provisions in construction contracts should be reviewed carefully, together with any relevant notices and the applicable statutory framework.

Delays and Extensions of Time

Construction projects can be affected by late instructions, design changes, supply problems, access issues, variations, contractor performance and events outside the parties’ control.

Disputes may arise over responsibility for the delay, entitlement to an extension of time and liability for additional costs or liquidated damages.

Defective Workmanship

A developer or employer may allege that work does not comply with the contract, specification, drawings or required standard. The contractor may dispute responsibility or argue that the alleged defect results from design, materials, instructions or work performed by another party.

Expert evidence can become particularly important where the technical cause of a defect is disputed.

Variations and Additional Works

Construction projects frequently change after work has started. Disputes can arise over whether a variation was properly instructed, whether additional payment is due and how the additional work should be valued.

Problems are particularly likely where changes were agreed informally without following the contractual procedure.

Breach of Contract

A party may allege that another party has failed to perform its contractual obligations. This could involve failure to complete work, failure to make payment, failure to provide access, failure to meet specifications or other contractual breaches.

Businesses involved in substantial contractual disagreements may also need to consider broader business and commercial law issues, particularly where the dispute affects financing, supply arrangements or other connected commercial agreements.

Termination of Construction Contracts

Ending a construction contract can have significant financial and legal consequences. A party considering termination should carefully review the contractual termination provisions and obtain appropriate advice before taking action.

An invalid termination can itself result in a substantial claim, making it particularly important to review notice requirements and contractual procedures before taking irreversible steps.

Professional Negligence

Claims may also arise against architects, engineers, surveyors, project managers and other construction professionals where it is alleged that their services fell below the required professional standard and caused financial loss.

What Should You Do When a Construction Dispute Begins?

Early decisions can have a significant effect on the eventual outcome of a construction dispute. Businesses should avoid treating the matter solely as an operational disagreement when it has the potential to develop into a formal legal dispute.

Relevant documents should be identified and preserved. Depending on the dispute, these may include:

  • the signed construction contract and amendments;
  • tender documents and specifications;
  • drawings and design documents;
  • payment applications and payment notices;
  • variation instructions;
  • project programmes and revised programmes;
  • site reports and meeting minutes;
  • emails and other correspondence;
  • photographs and inspection records;
  • invoices and financial records; and
  • expert or consultant reports.

The contract should then be reviewed to determine the parties’ rights, notice requirements, dispute resolution provisions, governing law and any contractual deadlines.

Failing to issue a required notice or taking action without following the agreed contractual procedure can materially affect a party’s position.

For businesses dealing with a developing disagreement, our guide on what to do when a business dispute escalates provides further guidance on approaching disputes strategically before formal proceedings become unavoidable.

Negotiating a Construction Dispute

Not every construction dispute needs to result in formal proceedings.

Commercial negotiation can sometimes resolve a dispute more quickly and preserve an ongoing business relationship. The strength of a negotiation position, however, will often depend on a clear understanding of the contractual rights, evidence and potential legal remedies available to each party.

Where appropriate, negotiations can continue alongside preparations for a more formal dispute resolution process.

Construction Adjudication

Adjudication is an important method of resolving construction disputes in the UK construction industry.

Under the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996, parties to qualifying construction contracts have statutory rights relating to adjudication.

The procedure is designed to provide a relatively rapid decision and is frequently used for disputes concerning payment, valuations, extensions of time, variations and contractual entitlements.

For contracts falling within the statutory regime, a party may generally refer a dispute to adjudication at any time. The statutory framework provides for a timetable intended to secure appointment of an adjudicator and referral of the dispute quickly, with the adjudicator ordinarily required to reach a decision within 28 days of referral, subject to permitted extensions.

An adjudicator’s decision is generally binding unless and until the dispute is finally determined through litigation, arbitration where applicable, or settlement between the parties.

Because adjudication moves quickly, parties involved in an adjudication should prepare their contractual documents, evidence and legal arguments carefully.

Mediation in Construction Disputes

Mediation provides a confidential process in which an independent mediator assists the parties in attempting to reach a negotiated settlement.

Unlike a judge or arbitrator, the mediator does not normally impose a decision. Instead, the objective is to help the parties identify areas of agreement and explore a commercially acceptable settlement.

Mediation can be particularly useful where the parties wish to control the outcome, avoid lengthy proceedings or preserve an important commercial relationship.

It may be used before proceedings begin or at a later stage as part of a wider dispute resolution strategy.

Construction Arbitration

Arbitration is frequently used for substantial construction and engineering disputes, particularly where projects involve international parties.

A construction contract may contain an arbitration clause requiring certain disputes to be referred to arbitration rather than determined through ordinary court proceedings.

Arbitration can offer several advantages in appropriate cases, including the ability to select arbitrators with suitable experience, procedural flexibility and the international recognition and enforcement framework available for many arbitral awards.

For international developers, contractors and investors, the arbitration clause within a construction agreement can therefore be an important part of the contract rather than merely a provision to consider after a dispute has arisen.

Arbitration in England, Wales and Northern Ireland is principally governed by the Arbitration Act 1996, as amended by the Arbitration Act 2025.

Businesses involved in cross-border projects can also read our detailed guide to international commercial arbitration and cross-border disputes.

Construction Litigation and the Technology and Construction Court

Some construction disputes ultimately require court proceedings.

The Technology and Construction Court, commonly known as the TCC, is a specialist court dealing with technically complex disputes, including construction, building and engineering claims. Its work can include contractual disputes, professional negligence claims and proceedings concerning adjudication and arbitration.

Official guidance from HM Courts & Tribunals Service explains the types of cases that may be brought before the Technology and Construction Court.

Whether court proceedings are appropriate depends on factors including the contract, value and complexity of the dispute, urgency, available remedies and whether the parties have agreed to another dispute resolution mechanism such as arbitration.

Before commencing proceedings, parties should also consider the applicable pre-action requirements and whether alternative dispute resolution may assist in resolving the dispute.

Construction Payment Disputes

Cash flow is particularly important within the construction industry, which makes payment disputes commercially significant.

A payment dispute may involve an employer and main contractor, a contractor and subcontractor, or other parties within the contractual chain.

Typical issues include:

  • unpaid applications for payment;
  • the valuation of completed work;
  • pay less notices;
  • retention;
  • variations;
  • loss and expense claims;
  • final account disputes; and
  • payment for additional works.

The contractual payment mechanism and any applicable statutory requirements should be examined carefully before deciding how to pursue or defend a payment claim.

Construction Contract Disputes

The wording of the underlying contract is often central to a construction dispute. Issues concerning payment, variations, extensions of time, termination, dispute resolution, governing law and liability will frequently depend on the contractual terms agreed by the parties.

This becomes particularly important where several contracts form part of the same project or where the parties have incorporated standard terms alongside project-specific amendments.

For further information about contractual risk in international transactions, see our guide to international commercial contracts and key legal issues for cross-border businesses.

Property and Development Issues

Construction projects can also overlap with wider property and development matters. Developers and commercial property owners may need to consider leases, ownership arrangements, acquisition documents, rights affecting the property or obligations connected with a wider commercial transaction.

B A International Solicitors also provides advice concerning commercial leases and conveyancing where property issues form part of a broader development or commercial matter.

International Construction Disputes

Construction projects increasingly involve businesses operating across several jurisdictions. A project may have overseas investors, international contractors, foreign suppliers and financing arrangements involving different countries.

International construction disputes can therefore raise additional questions beyond the underlying technical disagreement.

These may include:

  • which country’s law governs the contract;
  • which courts have jurisdiction;
  • whether disputes must be referred to arbitration;
  • where an arbitration should be legally seated;
  • how evidence located overseas will be handled;
  • how judgments or arbitral awards may be enforced; and
  • whether several related contracts contain inconsistent dispute resolution clauses.

These issues should ideally be addressed when contracts are negotiated. Once a dispute has arisen, however, understanding the governing law and dispute resolution provisions should be one of the first steps in determining the appropriate strategy.

Carefully drafted commercial agreements can reduce uncertainty, which is one reason why businesses entering significant projects should consider appropriate commercial legal advice before contracts are signed.

Construction Disputes Involving Middle Eastern Businesses

London is frequently used as a centre for international commercial transactions and dispute resolution. Businesses and investors from Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Qatar, Kuwait and other Middle Eastern jurisdictions may therefore become involved in contracts containing English governing law provisions, English jurisdiction clauses or London-seated arbitration agreements.

A dispute involving a Middle Eastern party and a UK project may require consideration of both the underlying construction issues and the international elements of the transaction.

For example, parties may need to consider contractual jurisdiction provisions, arbitration agreements, cross-border evidence and the eventual enforcement of a judgment or arbitral award against assets located in another jurisdiction.

Obtaining advice at an early stage can help businesses understand the available options before taking steps that may affect their contractual or procedural position.

Adjudication, Arbitration or Litigation: Which Is Appropriate?

There is no single dispute resolution method that is suitable for every construction dispute.

Adjudication may be particularly valuable where a rapid decision is required during an ongoing construction project.

Arbitration may be appropriate where the contract requires it or where the dispute is international and the parties value a private specialist process.

Litigation may be appropriate where judicial determination, specific court remedies or the specialist jurisdiction of the Technology and Construction Court is required.

Mediation and negotiation may also be used independently or alongside other procedures.

The correct approach depends on the contract, urgency, value of the claim, location of the parties and assets, evidence available and commercial objectives.

When Should You Speak to a Construction Dispute Solicitor?

Legal advice can be valuable before a dispute reaches formal proceedings.

Businesses may wish to seek advice where:

  • a significant payment has been withheld;
  • a formal contractual notice has been received;
  • termination is being considered;
  • an adjudication has been threatened or commenced;
  • substantial project delays have occurred;
  • defective work is alleged;
  • a major variation is disputed;
  • a contractor or employer is alleged to be in breach of contract; or
  • an international construction dispute is developing.

Early review of the contract and available evidence can help identify potential risks, procedural requirements and the most appropriate route towards resolution.

Our construction law solicitors can advise on the contractual and dispute resolution issues arising from construction and building projects.

How B A International Solicitors Can Assist

B A International Solicitors advises businesses and individuals on complex construction, commercial and dispute resolution matters, including disputes with an international or cross-border dimension.

Where a construction dispute involves contractual, commercial, litigation or arbitration issues, our team can assess the circumstances of the dispute, review the relevant contractual framework and advise on the available options for resolution.

Depending on the circumstances, this may involve advice relating to construction law, dispute resolution and litigation, or wider business and commercial law considerations.

For international businesses, we understand that the legal strategy must also take account of commercial relationships, jurisdiction, enforcement and the practical realities of operating across borders.

Frequently Asked Questions About Construction Disputes

What type of solicitor handles construction disputes?

Construction disputes are generally handled by solicitors experienced in construction law, commercial disputes, litigation, adjudication or arbitration. Complex cases may involve several of these areas, particularly where the project includes international parties.

How are construction disputes resolved in the UK?

Depending on the contract and circumstances, a construction dispute may be resolved through negotiation, mediation, adjudication, arbitration or litigation. Some contracts specify the procedure that the parties must follow.

How long does construction adjudication take?

For adjudication under the statutory construction regime, the framework is designed to operate rapidly. Subject to the applicable rules and permitted extensions, an adjudicator will ordinarily be required to reach a decision within 28 days after the dispute has been referred.

Can a construction dispute go to arbitration?

Yes. Construction and engineering contracts frequently contain arbitration agreements, particularly for major or international projects. Whether a dispute must be arbitrated will depend on the contractual arrangements and applicable law.

Can a contractor recover unpaid construction invoices?

Potentially. The appropriate method will depend on the contract, the payment mechanism, notices that have been issued, the nature of the debt and whether the amount is disputed. Adjudication is commonly used for certain construction payment disputes.

What happens when a construction project is delayed?

The consequences depend on the contract and the cause of the delay. Issues may include extensions of time, liquidated damages, additional costs, loss and expense and responsibility for the delaying event.

Can an overseas company bring a construction claim in England?

Potentially, yes. Whether proceedings can be brought in England will depend on matters including jurisdiction, the terms of the contract, governing law and any arbitration or jurisdiction agreement between the parties.

Which court deals with major construction disputes in London?

The Technology and Construction Court is a specialist court that deals with many complex construction, engineering and technology disputes in England and Wales. The Civil Procedure Rules specifically recognise building and construction disputes, including proceedings concerning the enforcement of adjudicators’ decisions, as matters that may be appropriate for the TCC.

Speak to Our Construction Dispute Solicitors

Construction disputes can become costly and disruptive if they are not addressed strategically. Whether the issue concerns payment, contractual performance, delay, defects, termination, adjudication, arbitration or a cross-border project, understanding the contractual and legal position at an early stage can help protect your commercial interests.

If you are involved in a construction dispute, our Construction Law team can advise on the issues affecting your project and the options available for resolving the dispute.

Contact B A International Solicitors to discuss a construction or commercial dispute with our London legal team.